Doomers' worst nightmare: a sustainable mid-tech, high culture global civilization, plagued by endless failing genocides.
Civilization would survive just fine. But it might not be a robust high-tech 21st century civilization. That might actually be a good thing - it's hard to tell.
I've written an essay explaining how I came to this conclusion. Medium says it should take about 8 minutes to read. But if that's too long for you, here's an extended summary.
The United States in early 2024 is in a political situation where collapse into a quasi civil war like "the troubles" in Ireland seems like a possibility. Elected politicians in Texas are calling for military-aided defiance of Federal authorities, supported by governors of 25 other states. But unlike the first US Civil War in the 1860s, there is no sign of the creation of large state armies to oppose the US Army, and the states themselves are internally divided to the point where a next war would be as much of a "war within the states" as a "war between the states". Nobody in the Texas Legislature is proposing to fund the Texas Military Department to a level where it would pose more than symbolic opposition to Federal forces. It's more likely that violent opposition to the United States would take the form of "stochastic terrorism" (I prefer the term "freelance terrorism") - bombings and random mass shootings. Whether these could become focused enough to target Federal buildings and political gatherings seems doubtful.
But it's interesting to imagine what might happen if the US went into a collapse as deep as the Great Depression of the 1920s, that somehow became permanent.
The global impact of US collapse would span five realms: general economic activity, social and cultural activity, geopolitics, technological development, and environmental stability.
The loss of the US as an economic force would severely but not seriously damage the global economy. The Dollar would lose its role as the world's reserve currency, and this would have a tremendous impact. The World Bank, the Euro, and the Chinese Renminbi are waiting to take over if the situation becomes intolerable, though.
Global culture would not be significantly affected. High culture of symphonic music, fine art, and fashion has always been ruled by Europe, and would stay that way.
Geopolitically, the long-predicted end of the Pax Americana would finally be realized, though the Great Game of pre-WWI colonialism is gone forever, never to return. The Mideast would continue to be the same mess of intra-Islamic jihadism that it's been since the end of the Ottoman Empire. China's dominance in the Far East would finally be unquestionable.
Attacks on Taiwan would lead to a major technological setback, since the most powerful semiconductors are made there by TSMC. Software to use the computational power of those semiconductor devices might lose its creative momentum that originates in Silicon Valley, The tech giants are fully globalized and can easily migrate transactions and data from their already fortified datacenters to ones in less unstable areas.
Advanced electric power technology would easily be able to fill in the gap caused by the loss of the US.
When it comes to transportation, the US is no longer the uncontested leader in technology, but only a participant in a close race. The US is losing its lead in aerospace technology. The US is not even in the running for the lead in advanced railroad technology. Automobile and truck technology has long been a global competition, and the loss of US auto manufacturing would wound employment in Mexico and Canada, but not significantly elsewhere.
The environment continues to be destroyed at a rate exceeding its restoration regardless of the details of civilizational conflicts, although there are macrotrends that act to slow the rate of destruction.
As long as the High Income countries (aside from the chaos-plagued US) continue to produce pollution-reducing solutions, as Low and Middle Income Countries graduate into the upper tier (and assuming that the World Bank and OECD don't move the dividing lines) their improving governance and economic incentives will lead them to reduce their emissions as well.
As we sum up the effects of US chaos in the five realms of global civilization beyond climate, it appears that short of a global thermonuclear war, the chief threats are related to reduction of silicon and lithium processing capability for computers, photovoltaic power sources and batteries. These capabilities are concentrated in the Western Pacific, and it's essential that the rest of the world build up resiliency against disruptions there.
As long as environmental and climate deterioration can be reversed, the worst that might happen would be a reversion to the American lifestyle that was pervasive in the 1970s, before everyone had PCs and smartphones. With Total Electric Homes and electric cars in garages, this could be quite tolerable.